Recent Reviews

25.02.2018

18.02.2018

11.02.2018

04.02.2018

28.01.2018

21.01.2018

[ More Music Reviews ]


Circa: Valley Of The Windmill
Circa Valley Of The Windmill CD Album Review

Circa: Valley Of The Windmill

Melodic Progressive Rock
3.5/5.0

Circa, the invention of and collaboration between Billy Sherwood and original Yes keyboard player Tony Kaye, continues with the release of their fifth album, Valley Of The Windmill. They're joined by two new additions, Ricky Tierney on bass and Scott Connor on drums. If you have some knowledge and experience with Circa you pretty much know where things are going.

Circa Valley Of The Windmill Band Photo

Circa

Circa and Valley Of The Windmill is prog. With more elaboration, this is melodic progressive rock in the classic tradition, leaning toward a more synthesizer forward sound. Additionally, the Circa sound moves towards the more lighter, gentler, side of prog. There's nothing particularly "heavy" about this album. The music is softer, airy, even ethereal at times, and lilting along. Alternatively, Our Place Under The Sun moves with a deeper groove, but nothing towards progressive metal. It's also the one song where Billy Sherwood's guitar lines seem more prominent.

Generally, with most prog albums there's something for every listener, and perhaps this is true for Valley Of The Windmill. But mostly the album reminded me of a warmed over mixture of Yes, Genesis, and Marillion. Additionally, for all the talent and creativity, I didn't find anything here to be all that memorable. Nothing really hooked me and kept me interested. (Perhaps the reason for this is that it seemed too keyboard present for me.) Valley Of The Windmill is an album that could be played in the background at a wine and cheese party and nobody would notice it. Not because it's boring, but because it's benign and circumspect. Nevertheless, while I came down on the side of ambivalence, Circa fans will likely find Valley Of The Windmill another pleasing addition to their catalog.


Share This Review with Your Friends





CraigHartranft.net - New fiction, crime fiction by Craig Hartranft

The Bottom Line

While I came down on the side of ambivalence, Circa fans will likely find Valley Of The Windmill another pleasing addition to their catalog.

Find A Review

Alphabetical Index

a b c d e f g h i j
k l m n o p q r s t
u v w x y z #
Album of the Week
Click to read the Shiraz Lane - Carnival Days CD Album review

On the strength of 2016's For Crying Out Loud, Shiraz Lane was quick to receive praise from reviewers and fans alike. The album led to sharing stages with bands across diverse genres including Halestorm ... [ Read More ]